Skip to main content
Polly Poke ItPiercings
Our ServicesServing Evansville

Piercing Jewelry & Fitting in Evansville, IN

We help Evansville clients pick and fit piercing jewelry, handle first-time downsizes, and safely change out jewelry once a piercing is healed.

Rated 5 on Google
Turnaround
Jewelry changes usually done in minutes
Areas served
Evansville, IN and nearby communities
Contact
Call or text (812) 470-6626

What's Included

  • Jewelry selection guidance
  • Sizing for your anatomy
  • First downsize after swelling
  • Jewelry changes on healed piercings
  • Threadless and threaded options
  • Ask about material options

/HOW IT WORKS

OUR PROCESS

  1. Step 01

    Reach Out or Walk In

    Call or text (812) 470-6626 to plan your visit, or just stop by during open hours. We welcome walk-ins and last-minute piercings whenever we have room.

  2. Step 02

    Consult and Choose Jewelry

    We check your anatomy, talk through placement, and help you pick jewelry that fits. If a spot isn't a good candidate, we tell you honestly before anything happens.

  3. Step 03

    Your Piercing

    Using sterile, single-use technique, your piercer marks the exact spot for your approval, then works cleanly and precisely, keeping you comfortable the whole time.

  4. Step 04

    Aftercare Guidance

    You leave with written aftercare instructions and a clear healing timeline, plus straight answers to any questions so you know exactly how to care for it.

  5. Step 05

    Come Back for a Downsize

    Once swelling settles, stop in for your first jewelry downsize or a change once it's healed. Follow-up questions are always welcome.

/REVIEWS

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS SAY

Contact Us Now
Customers consistently mention
  • highly recommend
  • feel comfortable
  • start to finish
  • you're looking

Got my helix there on a whim today, went with my friend to see if she had the anatomy for a naval piercing but I loved Arcey so much, I decided to go ahead and get something done while I was there. She was so welcoming and kind. Very knowledgeable and informative. I was nervous and she was so comforting and kept her cool, even letting me play the music I requested! Really really a great experience all around. If you're looking for anything, I recommend going to her!!! And I appreciate that she was open late!!!!

Jessica Schmitt

a month ago

I had an amazing experience with Arcey at Polly Poke It Piercing! Arcey was professional, friendly, and incredibly knowledgeable throughout the entire process. She took the time to explain everything, answered all of my questions, and made me feel comfortable and at ease. The studio was spotless, and her attention to safety and detail was obvious from start to finish. The piercing was done with precision, and I couldn't be happier with the results. If you're looking for a skilled piercer who genuinely cares about their clients, I highly recommend Arcey. I'll definitely be returning for future piercings!

Octavia Nubian Goddess

2 months ago

We had a great experience getting my nose pierced! The customer service was amazing from start to finish. Arcey was friendly, professional, and made us feel comfortable throughout the whole process. The shop was extremely clean and sanitary, which made us feel confident and at ease. She explained everything clearly and took her time to make sure everything was perfect. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a clean and welcoming place for piercings!

Christina Welch

2 months ago

I got two eyebrow piercings and a vertical labret, Arcey paid intense attention to detail, made sure to check anatomy and made the piercings fit with the contours of my face. I think that she has a very lovely and warm presence, made the piercing process very comforting, and had a lot of wonderful wisdom to impart on top of being an awesome artist. I look forward to working with her again!

skye wartooth

a month ago

I absolutely love Arceys piercing etiquette, she is very knowledgeable about what she does and is such a fun and unique person!! I plan on coming to her from now on for all my piercing needs and definitely will recommend to everyone i know! She did such a great job with my eyebrow piercing, I am so happy with it!!

Emma Clark

3 months ago

Review Us on Google

Leave Us a Review

Jewelry & Fitting Available In

We offer jewelry & fitting to customers across the region. Tap any area for full local details.

About Jewelry & Fitting

Common questions and tips from our work with Evansville customers.

Why do I need a downsize after piercing?
We start with slightly longer jewelry so there's room for early swelling. Once that settles, the extra length lets the piece move and snag, which slows healing. Coming back for a shorter, better-fitting piece keeps the piercing stable and comfortable. It's a quick visit and well worth it.
Can you change jewelry you didn't pierce?
In most cases, yes, as long as the piercing is healed and healthy. Bring the new jewelry or pick something in studio, and we'll safely swap it for you. If the piercing still looks irritated, we'll let you know and suggest waiting so we don't set your healing back.

Tip

Don't force a jewelry change

If jewelry won't go in easily, stop. Forcing it can tear the channel or push in the wrong angle. A tight or stubborn change usually means the piercing isn't fully healed, or the threading is off. Let a piercer handle it rather than risking damage at home.

FAQ

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Price depends on the piercing and the jewelry you choose, since a simple lobe and a curated cartilage setup aren't the same. We'll give you a clear total before anything happens, with no surprises. Call or text (812) 470-6626 for a quick quote, or stop by and we'll walk you through the options.

Both work. Plenty of our Evansville clients walk in on a whim, and reviewers regularly mention getting in last minute. If you want a guaranteed spot, especially for a group, call or text ahead. Either way, you'll get the same calm, unhurried experience once you're in the chair.

Yes. We're open until 10:00 PM, Wednesday through Monday, including Saturday and Sunday, and closed only on Tuesday. Being open late and on weekends is one of the things Evansville clients tell us they appreciate most, since it fits around work and school schedules.

Most piercings are a quick, sharp pinch that's over in a second. Lobes are the mildest, while cartilage and some body spots have a bit more pressure. We're known for keeping nervous, first-time clients comfortable, explaining each step and staying calm so you know exactly what to expect.

Keep it clean with sterile saline as directed, keep your hands off it, and avoid harsh products like alcohol or peroxide. We send you home with written aftercare instructions and are always happy to answer follow-up questions. If something looks off, come back in and we'll take a look.

Age and consent rules vary by piercing and by law, so please call or text (812) 470-6626 before you come in and we'll explain exactly what's required. Bring a valid photo ID for yourself, and if a minor is being pierced, ask us what documentation and guardian consent you'll need to bring.

Cleanliness is a point of pride, and clients repeatedly describe the studio as spotless with obvious attention to safety from start to finish. We use sterile, single-use needles and follow careful hygiene practices for every piercing. If you have specific questions about our process, just ask when you're in.

A single piercing usually takes about 15 to 30 minutes from consultation to aftercare, since we don't rush the placement or the explanation. More involved work, like multiple piercings or a curated ear, takes a bit longer. We'd rather take our time and get it right than hurry you through.

We fit you with jewelry sized to your anatomy and the specific piercing, and we'll walk you through the styles and options available in studio. If you have preferences about materials or design, bring them up and we'll help you choose a piece that fits comfortably and heals well.

We're on Tippecanoe Drive on Evansville's east side and serve clients from across the Tri-State, including Newburgh, Boonville, Chandler, Mount Vernon, and Henderson, Kentucky. If you're within driving distance of Evansville, you're welcome to book or walk in during our open hours.

Still have questions? Contact Us

READY FOR YOUR NEXT PIERCING?

BOOK OR WALK IN TODAY

or call (812) 470-6626